Welcome to Casa Nostra Restaurant
At Casa Nostra Restaurant, a charming family-run eatery in Sutton, authentic Italian cuisine takes center stage. Nestled on Mulgrave Road, this culinary gem delights diners with a menu brimming with homemade dishes. From delectable risottos to mouthwatering lasagna, each plate is crafted with care and passion. The warm, friendly atmosphere fosters connection, making it perfect for celebrations—evidenced by joyous birthday serenades from staff. Diners rave about the crispy whitebait, fresh salads, and standout pasta offerings. With a commitment to quality and service, Casa Nostra invites you to indulge in a truly Italian dining experience that feels like home.
Casa Nostra Restaurant: Reviews & Ratings
Went for my daughter's birthday, excellent service, very funny and friendly staff, delicious food that comes perfectly on time. Sang happy birthday with the whole restaurant and gave her a dessert on the house. Strongly recommend
Excellent food and friendly atmosphere. Went there to celebrate my friend's 50th birthday. From starters to mains to desserts, all the food was on point for everyone. There was a board with special s of the day which also had fabulous items. Definitely worth checking out if one is in Sutton
Super nice food ( pasta and pizza), and super friendly nice guys. Full of fun and humor. 100% recommend.
Wonderful experience from start to finish. I ate there solo, but saw how happy groups were enjoying their Easter dinner. I had Fried Whitebait, Salad, appetizer portion of Spaghetti Puttanesca, and Veal Milanese. The Whitebait was an experiment for me, never had before, but it was crispy and good to me, although honestly have no frame of reference to judge it. The things I can judge are the tasty Puttanesca sauce, delicious. And the veal, pounded thin, fried perfectly. Excellent.
- This Evening I Enjoyed an Absolutely Divine Italian Meal at Casa Nostra..... An Extremely Popular 5 Rated Family Owned and Run Italian Restaurant Opposite Sutton Station. This is No Zizzi, This is Proper Authentic Italian Cuisine in the Heart of Sutton. Mouthwatering Homemade Dishes Cooked to Absolutely Heavenly Perfection . ..... Why Haven't I Been Here Before?! .... I Tried to Visit Last Week but they Were Closed for Post New Year Holiday but hadn't updated Google which Still Showed as Open. Not to Worry I Rang at 6pm Today as I Fancied "Proper Italian" and Although They Were Packed They Managed to Fit Me In for 6.30pm until 8pm. I Turned Up at 6.20pm..... I had Diet Coke as my Drink (No Coca-Cola Zero) with Crispy Whitebait to Start with Garlic Mayonnaise which was Delicious...... Followed by the BEST MOST TASTIEST LASAGNE I'VE HAD IN MY LIFE!! ....... Melt In Your Mouth Succulence from the Spoon to My Tummy. It Was Absolutely Divine . No Hard Lasagna Sheet Ready Meal Version Here!! CONFIRMED HOME MADE!! For Dessert I had Chocolate and Mint Ice Cream Bombe Which was Minty Refreshing . I Was Worried about Fitting Everything In Before 8pm but I Was Ahead of Schedule and All Paid Up by 7.50pm ish. I Started by Rushing due to My Anxiety but I Made It. In any case, the couple next to me which arrived after me , finished before I did, so there was no need to panic! The Lot Came to 35.75 Including Service Charge Which I Thought Was Excellent..... It Costs that to eat at Whitbread Bar Block Steakhouse and A LOT is Pre Prepared Frozen There..... NOT Homemade Authentic Italian Cuisine. Oh and Veal is On the Menu, Both In Breadcrumbs and Without. The Waiter/Manager/Owner Said as Long as Mum Brings her Gluten Free Breadcrumbs they Can Do Veal in Breadcrumbs but Gluten-free! What An Enjoyable Meal..... I Was Originally Going to Have Risotto but I Think I'll be Back Next Week to Have That...... There's Just TOO MUCH Scrummy Italian Cuisine on the Menu to Choose! One thing's for sure Spaghetti Carbonara, Was a very popular dish this evening as I saw one after the other being brought out from the kitchen, past me! My new favourite Italian..... Must Bring Vitalie, My Italian Support Worker for Lunch Some Time, To see how a native finds it. Although natives run and own the restaurant, so I think he will agree it's the Best in the area, but there's only one way to find out!...... . Until Sometime Very Soon for Risotto..... -
The staff are friendly and warm. One shared with me how to take care of his cuddly teddy when he saw my rabbit. Please remember to see if any daily special. We are so lucky to have mango, avocado with crab and prawns. The fresh sweet mangoes are from their garden! Also, don’t miss their desserts! Thank you for the lovely lunch today xx
Came for date night. Food very lovely Great service Great selection of specials Would recommend
We celebrated birthday here in Casa Nostra. The starter with scallop and prawn is really amazing! We enjoyed a lot with the funny staff and their humor! Good vibe for birthday, anniversary and whatever you think important to your life! Highly recommended.
Location
-
8 Mulgrave Rd, Sutton SM2 6LE, United Kingdom Hotline: +44 20 8661 7284
Welcome to Casa Nostra Restaurant, a hidden gem in Sutton that truly embodies the heart and soul of authentic Italian cuisine. Nestled conveniently at 8 Mulgrave Rd, Sutton SM2 6LE, United Kingdom, this family-owned establishment has carved out a reputation for its warm atmosphere, delightful flavors, and impeccable service. With a cozy ambiance that welcomes both solo diners and families alike, there’s an undeniable charm that makes every visit a memorable experience.
- Culinary Highlights:
- Al Forno Delights: Indulge in classics like Crespolini Di Ricotta, Cannelloni, and Lasagne Al Forno, crafted with love and precision, ensuring each bite transports you to Italy.
- Salads That Refresh: The Insalata Casanostra and Pomodoro É Cipolla present vibrant, fresh ingredients that are anything but ordinary, setting a perfect tone for your meal.
- Hearty Mains: Dive into culinary masterpieces like Lombo Di Maiale and Salmon Di Natale, alongside the spicy yet tender Gnocchi Arrabiata, making each main an exploration of flavor.
The heartwarming reviews reflect a consistent commitment to exceptional hospitality. Customer 최정희 shared an enchanting birthday celebration experience, noting the staff's humor and the delightful surprise dessert for her daughter. Geraldine Igbenoba commended the restaurant for its seamless execution from starters to desserts, emphasizing the daily specials which add an element of surprise and distinction to the menu.
Richard Cowdery, a devoted patron, highlighted the divine homemade dishes, confidently declaring Casa Nostra as a standout choice for authentic Italian fare. His experience with the Lasagne is particularly telling—what he described as “melt-in-your-mouth succulence” leaves you yearning for a taste of the past. Similarly, Steve Lauro applauded the flavor-packed dishes, proving that every plate is a testament to the restaurant's dedication to traditional Italian cooking.
Whether you’re looking to celebrate a special occasion or simply craving a comforting meal with friends, Casa Nostra Restaurant promises an experience filled with joy, warmth, and the richness of Italian culture. As the delightful aromas waft from the kitchen and the laughs echo around the dining room, you’ll find that each visit not only fills your stomach but warms your heart.
Make your reservation today by calling +44 20 8661 7284, and allow yourself to be swept away into the rich culinary heritage of Italy, right here at Casa Nostra.